How would those people convicted of capital crimes and later exonerated and freed from death row feel about "immediate public hangings."
As of Nov. 3, 2009, there have been 139 exonerations in 26 different states, including five in Georgia, according to The Death Penalty Information Center. There is a reason for the process in place.
Don't get me wrong, those who truly commit capital crimes should face the consequences of their actions. But the judicial process involves people, and people - even with the best of intentions - can be fallible.
Please provide a source for you figures. I'm just curious.
But if what you post is true, I think the reason is that there is no immediate consequence. If there was, prosecuters would be more diligent and the innocent would hire better lawyers.
#5
Observer of the observer
on
02/03/10 at 07:58 PM
Well mr. observer, It would be obvious to any one with any small portion of a brain to realize that if immediate publice hangings were enforced the amount of capital crimes would be greatly greatly greatly reduced !! Duhhhhhhhh.... Lose a few innocent to save thousands of innocent lives !!!! I'm all for it. Let God who is the only real Judge sort them out after death, If they were innocent it won't be any suprise to him..... So yes I did get you wrong ....
As of Nov, 2009....139 exonerations have been granted. Ok, so let’s subtract that number from the number of inmates incarcerated in the USA as in 2008, 2,424,279. 139 people in how many years? Not just in 2009? Hummm...let’s see
2,424,279 - 139 = 2,424,140
Hardly seems to be a monumental factor in comparison to the reintroduction of capital punishment. The sheer numbers of incarcerated speak volumes and the message is the legal system is not reducing or projecting an effective deterrent to crime.
In response to the first question, re-read my previous post. I cited the source
In response to "Observer of the observer," Wow! What if it was someone you knew on death row and you truly believed that person was wrongly convicted? Would you not take advantage of the process of appeals in place? And how does the death of an innocent person save lives? Does facing the possibility of a speeding ticket keep a lot of people from speeding? Just drive along Highway 19 and see.
And Mathematician, compare apples to apples - people on death row to those exonerated, not the total of those incarcerated to those exonerated of a capital crime.
I am speaking of a process, not of the laws and punishment. Criminals should be punished. I just happen to think we basically have a sound judicial process.
Most of them are out on bail awaitin trial. Yes the murd. Are in jail and we keep them up. But really do you want them walkin the streets? Kept it real people the ones that 'We are keepin up til trail need to be where they are.
I am ready to see what comes of the man that molested a young lady in my church.Then said he would never would harm a child, as he was begining to pack up and leave town. His case is coming up too. Wonder will he get what he deserves! More than likely not he will get a slap on the wrist and do it again to another. Its a shame that adults stand up for the trash that happens.
You all act like this is a shocker to you, but heres a reality chech for you. this world that we live in is messed up, every cenimeter of it along with every body I mean Everybody including myself. Our world is sick and dying along with the people who live in it.
"Now all we can do is wait as our world self-destructs as we watch from behind the glass."
We need to bring back immediate public hangings when someone is convicted of a capital crime.
As of Nov. 3, 2009, there have been 139 exonerations in 26 different states, including five in Georgia, according to The Death Penalty Information Center. There is a reason for the process in place.
Don't get me wrong, those who truly commit capital crimes should face the consequences of their actions. But the judicial process involves people, and people - even with the best of intentions - can be fallible.
But if what you post is true, I think the reason is that there is no immediate consequence. If there was, prosecuters would be more diligent and the innocent would hire better lawyers.
As of Nov, 2009....139 exonerations have been granted. Ok, so let’s subtract that number from the number of inmates incarcerated in the USA as in 2008, 2,424,279. 139 people in how many years? Not just in 2009? Hummm...let’s see
2,424,279 - 139 = 2,424,140
Hardly seems to be a monumental factor in comparison to the reintroduction of capital punishment. The sheer numbers of incarcerated speak volumes and the message is the legal system is not reducing or projecting an effective deterrent to crime.
In response to "Observer of the observer," Wow! What if it was someone you knew on death row and you truly believed that person was wrongly convicted? Would you not take advantage of the process of appeals in place? And how does the death of an innocent person save lives? Does facing the possibility of a speeding ticket keep a lot of people from speeding? Just drive along Highway 19 and see.
And Mathematician, compare apples to apples - people on death row to those exonerated, not the total of those incarcerated to those exonerated of a capital crime.
I am speaking of a process, not of the laws and punishment. Criminals should be punished. I just happen to think we basically have a sound judicial process.
"Now all we can do is wait as our world self-destructs as we watch from behind the glass."
I did a bit more research and there are at least 3 different sites including the one you reference that claim different numbers.
All of these sites including the one you referenced are places that work to exonerate those "wrongly" convicted.
Could these figures be self-serving?
Oh and for the numbers death row inmates represent 1/4 of 1% (6061). So 139 would be a 2.2% error rate.
Do you have any official statistics on the subject?